Response of Plasmodium falciparum to different antipalludic treatments:implications for the evolution of resistance
In spite of the effort to fight Malaria, the size of the phenomenon is not
decreasing. Furthermore, the resistance to the widest used drugs has spread
since 1960. Those drugs have the characteristic to be long lasting in the
organism. Since using one drug is not enough, new strategies use a
combination of two drugs to take advantage of the multiplicative effect of
mutation probabilities. Since the probability of mutation to be resistant
to one drug is nevertheless low, the probability to be resistant to two
drugs can be thought to be the product of both probabilities.
The combination uses usually a drug with long half-life, protected with a
short half-lived drug. When taking both the drugs, the decrease of the
population is considerable. When the short-lived drug has disappeared, the
long lasting one still remains. The remaining population of parasites in
presence of the residual drug is statistically to small to show a
mutation, and is eliminated by the long lasting drug.
I tried to simulate the evolution of the transmission of resistance to the
two drugs entering in the combination, using a model of differential equations.
First, I simulated the comportment of the population of parasites in
presence of immune cells, and without drug, so I could estimate the time
for the symptoms (3% of parasitemia) of the disease to emerge. I added then
one drug at this moment (9th day). Has we could imagine, all the sensitive
parasites disappeared, leaving only those resistant. Then the immune cells
eliminated all the remaining parasites. The cumulative production of
resistant gametocytes (those transmitted by the mosquito) was very high
(concentration reached 1e6 /ml after 20 days).
Then I made a simulation with variable concentrations of two different
half-lived and effectiveness drugs, and without immune cells. For a
definite combination of concentrations, the result showed a total
elimination of the parasites, without high production of gametocytes.
I tested the length of protection of the patient with drug combination,
against new infestation.
With the effective concentrations of drugs found before, I simulated the
production of resistant gametocytes according to the influence of a second
injection of parasites by a mosquito, and the variation of the mortality of
the immune cells.
For an injection of sensitive parasites, the result showed a protection
against parasite’s new installation, and therefore, no production of
resistant parasite, of about 5 days after the ingestion of medicaments, and
a longer period for a very low immune cells’ mortality (0.1/day). If the
injection takes place after the protection, during a low drug concentration
period, it gives a higher production of resistant parasites than an early
injection, during high concentration of drug.
With an injection of sensitive plus both simple-resistant parasites (2%),
the protection is only about one day, depending mainly on the short
half-lived drug. Furthermore, if the parasites’ injection takes place
after this protecting period, the production is mainly composed of long
lasting medicaments resistant, and double resistant parasites.
Often, the rising of the secondly injected parasites is only delayed by the
sub lethal remaining drugs. So the immune cells population has time to
decrease to its ground equilibrium concentration, taking more time to rise
again to eliminate parasites when parasitemia becomes high for the second time.
We notice that the creation of resistant parasites to the short half-lived
drug remains rare, whereas the resistance for the long half-lived drugs
takes often place, in the condition of experiment. This shows that this
(simplistic) treatment is, theoretically, usable to cure patients in
healthy regions, but must be improved when used in regions with
re-infestation, even when resistance is not yet established, since the
protection of a (long half-lived drug) by an other (short half-lived) is
not complete.